Project 138

The Practice of Ukutwala

The practice of ukuthwala has been a burning issue for some time, reaching its climax in March 2009 when the SABC and eTV evening television news reported on the prevalence of "forced marriages" and the "sale" of young girls into marriages with older men. The practice reportedly occurred mainly in Eastern Pondoland in Lusikisiki, Flagstaff, Bizana and other areas in the Eastern Cape Province. The news coverage also revealed that:

  • girls between the ages of 12 and 15 years are subjected to ukuthwala;
  • such girls are at times forced to marry men who are HIV positive;
  • some girls from the areas mentioned above were hiding in Gauteng and KwaZulu- Natal in fear of becoming victims of the practice;
  • the practice of ukuthwala was defended as being a traditional cultural practice, with adherents claiming that the tradition allows a man to abduct a woman whom he wishes to marry, even if he has not proposed love; and
  • such abductions mainly happen when young girls are on their way to school or are fetching water or wood.

Media Statements

Questionnaires & Workshops

Discussion Papers

  • Revised Discussion Paper 132 (Project 138) The Practice of Ukuthwala. Dated October 2015. Released 28 October 2015.
    Closing date for comments: 31 January 2016
  • Discussion Paper 132 (Project 138) The Practice of Ukuthwala. Dated May 2017. Released 01 September 2017
    Closing date for comments: 31 January 2016.

Report

  • Report on Project 138: The Practice of Ukuthwala. Released 29 March 2022.

    The investigation focused mainly on the distortion of the practice of ukuthwala. The main recommendation is the enactment of a new legislation called the Prohibition of Forced Marriage and Regulation of Related Matters Bill, which can be summarised as follows:

    1. The creation of the following offences: the offences of forced marriage; child marriage. It is further recommended that it should be a criminal offence for anyone to attempt; conspire with any other person; or aid, abet, induce, incite, instigate, instruct, command, counsel or procure another person to enter into a forced marriage or child marriage.

    2. Victims of forced marriage and child marriage or any person may apply for a forced marriage protection order which is a remedy that may contain such prohibitions, restrictions, requirements or other terms that the court may consider appropriate for the purposes of granting the order.

    3. A court may, in addition to any punishment which it may impose in respect of any offence provided for in the Bill, order a person convicted of such offence to pay appropriate compensation to the victim of the offence for any damages suffered by the victim.

    4. Victims of forced marriage and child marriage be afforded with a suitable accommodation and receive treatment until such time that they are fit and ready to face the world.

    5. The Minister of Justice and Correctional Services make regulations for –
    (a) the procedure to be followed in obtaining a forced Marriage Protection Order;
    (b) the procedure that must be followed when seeking an order for declaration of invalidity of forced marriage or child marriage;
    (c) national guidelines, instructions and training programmes that must be provided to various stakeholders to ensure effective implementation if the Bill.
    (d) the nature of facilities, conditions and circumstances under which victims of child marriage and forced marriage must be treated; and
    (e) the norms and standards of any place of safety or shelter.

    6. The Report further recommends that public awareness programmes or other measures for the prevention of forced marriage and child marriage should be established.