Project 121
Consolidated Legislation pertaining to International Co-peration in Civil Matters
There are a number of different statutes regulating international co-operation in civil matters. The investigation is aimed at reviewing this legislation with a view to developing a uniform Act which promotes the aims and achieves the purposes of the current individual Acts. It also aims to ascertain whether consolidation of legislation is the appropriate route to follow in attempting to facilitate international co-operation in civil matters.
International co-operation in the context of the Commission's investigation relates to the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments; the service of judicial process abroad; and the taking of evidence for use in foreign civil proceedings. Recognition of a foreign judgment means that a domestic court acknowledges that the judgment has, within its own jurisdiction, the legal effect which the foreign court intended it to have. Enforcement means that the domestic court will compel the judgment debtor to comply with the judgment. It is possible for a court to recognise a foreign judgment but not enforce it. It is, however, not possible for a court to enforce a foreign judgment without recognising it.
On 14 February 2002 South Africa became the 59th member State of the Hague Conference on Private International Law. This has opened the door for ratification of the Hague Conventions on Private International Law, which in turn are intended to foster international co-operation in civil and commercial matters.
Media Statements
- Media statement regarding the release of the Report on Project 121: Consolidated Legislation pertaining to International Co-Operation in Civil Matters, 15 August 2008.
Issue Papers
- Issue Paper 21 Consolidated Legislation Pertaining To International Co-Operation In Civil Matters (Project 121), 2003.
Closing date for comments: 28 February 2003.
Discussion Papers
- Discussion Paper 106 Consolidated legislation pertaining to international Co-operation in civil matters (Project 121), 2004
Closing date for comments: 30 September 2004
Report
- Project 121: Consolidated Legislation pertaining to International Co-Operation in Civil Matters (December 2006)
Released: 18 August 2008.
South Africa should be clearly committed to a policy of international judicial co-operation. In order to achieve this goal, we need to clarify and improve our law. As a starting point, gaps and ambiguities in the common law must be remedied. Reform of this area then provides a good opportunity to consider the state of our statute law. Repeal of the Protection of Businesses Act 99 of 1978, in particular, is essential if the South African legal system is to be made more amenable to international co-operation.
These reforms will obviously redound to the benefit of litigants seeking to serve process, take evidence or enforce foreign judgments locally, but urgent attention must also be paid to the plight of South African litigants who wish to perform the same acts abroad. Unless an international agreement is negotiated in advance to secure an accelerated procedure under one of our domestic statutes, the judgment creditor is at the mercy of the domestic law of the state in which enforcement is sought.