Project 90
Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law
Customary marriages, Conflict of personal laws, Traditional courts and the judicial function of traditional leaders, Administration of Estates & Customary Law of Succession
In 1986 the Commission published a report on its investigation into the marriages and customary unions of Black persons (Project 51). Two Bills were recommended in the report. The first resulted in the Marriage and Matrimonial Property Law Amendment Act 3 of 1988. The second Bill dealt with the customary marriages of Black persons. With regard to this Bill the Commission recommended that further consultations with the leadership of the TBVC states and the self-governing states should take place. After a series of high- level meetings the proposal that the so-called customary union be recognized as a valid marriage was endorsed: however, on 10 April 1992 the Minister ordered that the implementation of the Bill be suspended until the constitutional position of the TBVC states and the self-governing territories was clarified.
The matter was subsequently referred to the newly-formed Project Committee on the Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law, whose term of office lapsed together with that of the Commission. The new Commission, at a meeting on 23 and 24 February 1996, approved the reconstitution of the Project Committee1 and the ranking proposed by the outgoing committee, which had identified the law of marriage and divorce as a priority area. The new Project Committee had its first meeting on 7 June 1996 at which it decided to revive the issue of customary marriage. To this end the committee developed an issue paper which set out the nature of the problems in respect of customary marriages and a range of proposals for addressing these problems. The main proposal was that full recognition should be granted to customary marriages, in confirmation of the position adopted by the Commission in its 1986 report.
The investigation into this topic was launched formally with the publication, on 28 April 1998, of an Issue Paper under the auspices of Project 90: The Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law. The Issue Paper posed a number of questions about the extent and scope of the investigation, and about the substance of customary law in the area of succession.
In May 1998, as the responses were coming into the Commission, the Department of Justice responded to the mounting pressure for action by developing a draft Bill. This Bill was submitted to Cabinet in June 1998 and then introduced in Parliament as the Customary Law of Succession Amendment Bill 1998. The Bill extended the general law of succession as embodied in the Wills Act 7 of 1953 and the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987 (hereafter the Intestate Succession Act), to all persons by the simple expedient of including within the terms of the latter Act all persons previously covered by section 23 of the Black Administration Act 38 of 1927.
Media Statements
- Media statement on the release of the Report on traditional courts and the judicial function of traditional leaders, 21 January 2003.
- Media statement regarding the Investigation into Customary Law of Succession (Project 90), 7 March 2008.
Issue Papers
- Issue paper 03: Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law (Customary Marriages), 1997
- Issue paper 04: Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law (The Application of Customary Law: Conflict of Personal Laws), 1996
Discussion Papers
- Discussion Paper 74: The Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law: Customary Marriages, 1998
- Discussion Paper 76: Harmonisation of customary and common law: Conflict of personal laws, 1998
- Discussion Paper 82: Traditional courts and the judicial function of traditional leaders, 1999
- Discussion Paper 93: Customary Law of Succession, 2000
- Discussion Paper 95: Customary Law: Administration of Estates, 2001
Report
- Report on Project 90: Harmonisation of the common law and indigenous law: Customary marriages, August 1998.
- Reports on Project 90: The Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law: Conflicts of Law, September 1999.
Courts and litigants need clear and explicit choice of law rules to indicate when common or customary law will be applicable to the facts of a particular case. A new enactment devoted exclusively to the application of customary law is now needed in order to disentangle choice of law rules from the two statutes currently regulating this issue: the Black Administration Act (which has close association with the policies of segregation and apartheid) and the Law of Evidence Amendment Act (which is mainly concerned with ways of proving foreign and customary systems of law). - Report on Project 90: Customary Law Report - Report on traditional courts and the judicial function of traditional leaders, January 2003
The report contains draft legislation which is aimed at establishing customary courts and consolidating the different provisions governing chiefs' courts. The report attempts to convey a sense of the discussions and debates that took place in the different fora during this process and to express the dilemmas faced by the project committee and the Commission in choosing whatever options have eventually been adopted in the draft Bill. - Report on Project 90: Customary Law of Succession, April 2004 (Released: 06 March 2010).
The Black Administration Act of 1927 did not codify or define African customary law. It simply singled out Africans as a separate segment of society, subject to a different, discriminatory set of rules and laws, under the apartheid system. It provided that all Africans were subject to African customary law. Therefore, the African customary law rule of male primogeniture applied. The purpose of the report is to reform the customary rule of male primogeniture. The Constitutional Court has, in Bhe and Others v Magistrate, Khayelitsha, and Others (Commission for Gender Equality as Amicus Curiae); Shibi v Sithole and Others; South African Human Rights Commission and Another v President of the Republic of South Africa and Another 2005 (1) SA 580 (CC), ruled that the customary rule of male primogeniture law is unconstitutional. The report contains draft legislation which is intended to modify the customary law of succession so as to provide for the devolution of certain property in terms of the law of intestate succession; to clarify certain matters relating to the law of succession and the law of property in relation to persons subject to customary law; and to amend certain laws in this regard.