Project 71
Protection of the Child Witness
As a result of representations made to the Minister of Justice, Mr H J Coetsee, MP, relating to the protection of children with regard to court proceedings, the Minister requested the Commission on 8 November 1988 to undertake an investigation be instituted into the giving of evidence by children in litigation involving allegations of indecent acts and that in particular consideration be given to the following possible protective measures and procedures:
- That a child giving evidence in a trial be assisted by a representative.
- That the identification of a suspect by a child ought not to take place in open court, but from behind a one-way mirror.
- That the evidence of a child be heard in an informal atmosphere, which includes the hearing of such evidence in a room other than a court of law, and which also includes the possibility of hearing the child's evidence whilst the child is screened off by a one-way mirror or in the absence of the accused.
- That the pre-trial questioning of the child be carried out by a psychologist appointed by the court, who must be entitled to express his opinion in court regarding the child's credibility; such questioning to take place in consultation with the accused, the prosecution and the presiding officer.
- That video tapes relating to interviews between the child and a social worker during the investigation stages of the case ought to be admissible in court and ought to be made available to the accused before the trail.
The Commission clarified that all the recommendations below should apply to all child witnesses in a criminal court.
Working Papers
- Working Paper 28 (Project 071): Pretection of the Child Witness, 13 June 1989. Closing date for comment: 31 August 1989.
Report
- Report on Project 71: Report on the Protection of Child Witness (February 1991)
This report contains a draft Bill aimed at amending the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977, so as to provide for a child under the age of eighteen years who gives evidence to be assisted by an intermediary; to provide for cros.s-examination of a child under the age of eighteen years; to provide that a child under the age of eighteen years may give evidence elsewhere other than in open court; and to provide for matters incidental thereto.