Media Statement

Minister of Justice concludes visit to Palm Ridge Magistrates’ Court, vows urgent reforms

13 March 2025

The Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development, Mmamoloko Kubayi, has concluded her visit to the Palm Ridge Magistrates’ Court, expressing deep concern over the state of affairs and vowing to take decisive action to transform not only this court but others across the country.

During her engagement with community members, court staff, and officials, Minister Kubayi was confronted with alarming issues, including reports of procedural violations, inadequate service delivery, and a lack of accountability. Community members voiced frustration, where justice is alleged to be dispensed hastily and without due consideration for victims' rights.

Serious concerns were raised about judicial conduct, including allegations that magistrates intimidate victims, exclude them from crucial discussions, and grant bail under questionable circumstances.

The Minister was also appalled by the poor handling of gender-based violence (GBV) case files, describing the conditions as unacceptable and demanding immediate corrective measures.

"The weaknesses I witnessed today confirm the complaints we have been receiving. I personally instructed that certain issues be addressed before I leave, and I will ensure follow-ups are made," said Minister Kubayi. Poor staff attitudes, lack of adherence to court principles, and systemic inefficiencies were also highlighted as key problems.

The Minister acknowledged that some of these issues stem from a lack of support from head office, further exacerbating frustrations at the court level. She also raised concerns over security measures, citing an incident where crucial surveillance footage was unavailable due to a flawed data retention policy.

Minister Kubayi emphasized the need for urgent reforms, including stronger oversight, improved management, and accountability for failures, while she also reassures the public of her commitment to uphold the separation of powers and respect for judicial independence.

The Minister committed to engaging national and provincial leadership to address these systemic issues and ensure the justice system functions effectively for all South Africans.

"The justice system cannot be a place where people are forced to ‘buy justice.’ That is a direct violation of our Constitution. I take full responsibility and will not stand idly by while citizens suffer at the hands of a broken system," said the Minister.

The Minister has also issued an apology to affected citizens and stakeholders, acknowledging the failures in the system.

The Minister assured them that immediate interventions will be made, and changes will be implemented at the Palm Ridge Magistrates’ Court as a matter of priority.

 

Media Enquiries
Mr Terrence Manase
Spokesperson: Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Development
082 338 6707

Issued by the Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Development of the Republic of South Africa