Justice Home The Constitution Flag

Speeches

Home> Newsroom> Speeches

Remarks by the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development, Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi, Engagement with Law Students, 15 June 2026

Programme director Ms. Tumelo Zwane
Professor Ian Jandrell, Deputy Vice Chancellor: Systems and Operations
Professor Jason Cohen,Dean of the Faculty of Commerce, Law and Management
Daven Dass, SAULCA president
Mr. Peter Tshisevhe, TGR Attorneys
Leadership of NADEL, SAWLA, BLA and JSA
Distinguished guests
Ladies and Gentlemen
Good morning

We are gathered here on this day, a day before we celebrate the 50th anniversary of the June 16 Soweto uprising when hundreds of schoolchildren rose in protest against an unjust and dehumanising apartheid system, to reflect on the state of our constitutional democracy. Young people who aspired to play a greater role in shaping their destiny, rejected the imposition of the inferior education in schools designed to train Africans for their inferior role in apartheid society. They pursued their mission with courage and iron determination and in the end they victorious.

Perhaps the other important lesson we can draw from the June 16 uprising which is relevant to today’s gathering is the fact that the law can be used as an instrument for oppression. It was an array of carefully crafted laws which made up the oppressive system that was apartheid. These laws were designed to exclude, oppress and deny the humanity of the majority of South Africans.

The blood that was spilled in the streets of Soweto 50 years ago laid a foundation for an intensified struggle that led to the 1994 democratic breakthrough. It was this breakthrough that created a conducive environment for the drafting and the adoption of the South African constitution in 1996. The adoption of the constitution marked a revolutionary shift from an oppressive apartheid law to a legal framework whose central tenet is the transformation of society to a truly equal society in which citizens enjoy political, civil and socioeconomic rights.

In the words of Frantz Fanon, “Each generation must, out of relative obscurity, discover its mission, fulfill it, or betray it.” The 1976 generation identified as their mission the destruction of the system of apartheid and they never betrayed. It was this generation that injected impetus into the armed struggle which was instrumental in bringing apartheid to its knees.  So determined were they that by the late 1980s apartheid was no longer sustainable and its collapse created a platform which you who are gathered here today can utilise to fulfil your own mission. The platform I am speaking about is our transformative constitution.

As young people and future law practitioners you find yourself in context in which our country’s constitution has called on all of us to work together to Heal the divisions of the past and establish a society based on democratic values, social justice and fundamental human rights and Improve the quality of life of all citizens and free the potential of each person. Put simply, the constitution calls on all of us to work together to transform our society into one that is inclusive.

As a generation you have your work cut out for you. Transformation of our society will be the standard by which your generation will be judged. What the record of these thirty years of constitutional democracy reveals is that the communities that bore the heaviest cost of apartheid's deliberate impoverishment have not experienced the expected socioeconomic transformation that the Constitution envisaged. Those who were systematically denied access to property, education, and the basic conditions of a dignified life have found that, while the legal order has been fundamentally reengineered, their material circumstances have not shifted with commensurate decisiveness.

This is the central tension that three decades of constitutional democracy has not yet resolved. The constitutional framework has proven its resilience, in the courts, the legislature, and in the institutions created to give it effect. What has not kept pace is the translation of that framework into the daily lives of those it was most urgently intended to serve. That remains the most consequential measure by which this constitutional project will continue to be assessed.

The truth is that to further transform the society at a pace that will meet the expectation and aspirations of our fellow citizens will require men and women who are equipped with the educational tools to carry out this task. It requires men and women whose combines an optimal balance between formal academic and practical skills training. The question that arises is: are we equipping our law students with the correct and necessary skills to enable them to carry-out the transformation that our constitution envisages?

The deliberations today must also reflect on this question so that we can produce legal practitioners who are fit for purpose. In this regard, former Chief Justice Pius Langa also reflected on legal education under a constitutional democracy in his paper delivered at Stellenbosch university entitled “Transformative Constitutionalism” and amongst other things he wrote the following:

“We can no longer teach the lawyers of tomorrow that they must blindly accept legal principles because of the authority. No longer can we responsibly turn out law graduates who are unable to critically engage with the values of the Constitution and who are unwilling to implement those values in all corners of their practices.”

He went further to say that: “A truly transformative South Africa requires a new approach that places the Constitutional dream at the very heart of legal education. It requires that we regard law as part of the social fabric and teach law students to see it as such. They should see law for what it is, as an instrument that was used to oppress in the past, but that has that immense power and capacity to transform our society.”

In terms of academic training, there has been a diversity of views regarding the current structure of the LLB qualification. There are Law firms and some in the legal profession whose view is that law students are not prepared for the legal profession with a 4-year LLB because they lack maturity, numeracy skills, literary skills and critical thinking amongst other prerequisites for legal practice. This raises another question: are turning out law graduates who are unable to critically engage with the values of the Constitution and who are unwilling to implement those values in all corners of their practices? I am no expert in this matter, whether this has merit or not I cannot judge but I think it is matter that requires our attention because it has a bearing on the future of the legal profession.

With regards to practical training, the role of law clinics cannot be understated. Law clinics provide law students a workshop in which they can acquire practical experience. Students get an opportunity to test their understanding of theoretical concepts learned in the classroom. Law clinics usually represent the indigent who in most cases cannot afford representation and they take up cases that other practitioners are reluctant to take which essentially makes them important agents for expanding access to justice. Law students acquire practical and important skills required of them in practice, such as drafting.

For our part as the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development we have implemented a number of targeted initiatives to address the entry barriers faced by law graduates. Together with key justice sector institutions, the Department has implemented a range of targeted and complementary initiatives in partnership with institutions such as SASSETA, PSETA, etc, aimed at broadening access to the legal profession.

These include Candidate Attorney, Articleship and Internship programmes within the Offices of the State Attorney with a cohort of about Four hundred and six (406); One thousand and sixty-three (1063) candidates taken up by Legal Aid South Africa; the National Prosecuting Authority through the Aspirant Prosecutor Programme  has recruited a Hundred and eleven (111) LLB Graduates and the Special Investigating Unit  has recruited Forty-five (45) LLB Graduates, into a program that provide structured practical legal training while advancing transformation and access to justice.

These initiatives are designed to provide workplace exposure, skills development, and mentorship within specialised legal, investigative, and litigation environments, while balancing transformation objectives with operational, security, and capacity considerations across the justice sector.

It goes without saying that for you to shape a just future and to contribute to the transformation project you will need to adhere to a high ethical standard. Some few months back it was reported that unscrupulous lawyers have plundered their clients’ trust funds to the tune of R1.4 billion with more than 500 cases documented. These types of reports should worry all of us. Another ethical issue has to do with the usage of Artificial Intelligence, especially large language models, to draft legal papers. Recently, we have seen several cases that have exposed law firms and practitioners that have used AI without disclosing which is highly unethical. Undoubtedly, AI is still going to cause further disruption in the legal sector and whatever shape that takes the issue of ethics should never be compromised.

It is a reality which none of you who are today will be able to escape, a day will come in which you will have to make choice between on the one hand doing the right thing and disadvantaging yourself and on the other, doing the wrong thing and advantaging yourself. Those who are involved in the R1.4 billion scandal chose the latter. I would like to believe that those who have been ethically compromised are in the minority. There are still many man and women who have integrity, men and women who will do the right thing even if it disadvantages them. These are the men and women that our country needs to drive the transformation project who fulfillment is necessary for the stability and the sustainability of our constitutional democracy.

As we celebrate 30th year anniversary of the adoption of the Constitution, let us stand together and say: “One Constitution, One Nation – Reflect, Renew, Recommit.” Together, these themes call on all South Africans to recommit to constitutional values, inclusive development, and shared responsibility for nation building.

I thank you